A study published this year in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships followed 373 newlywed couples for 16 years, surveying both partners in years 1, 3, 7 and 16. The sample was 199 Black American couples and 174 White American couples, which matters, because the findings did not land the same way for everyone.
The researchers were testing something most people assume they already know: how much the people around a marriage affect whether it lasts.
Friends turned out not to predict much at all. Family did.
But the shape of the finding is not the one you would guess, and it changes what you should be asking before you marry someone.
What family actually does to a marriage
Here is the authors’ own summary of what they found:
A good marriage can protect you from an unsupportive family, but a supportive family cannot fully protect a struggling marriage.
Read that twice, because it cuts against both of the popular positions.
It is not true that family does not matter, which is the thing people say when they are in love and do not want to hear it. Marriages were least stable when the marriage and the family were both strained, and the effect was real over 16 years.
It is also not true that a difficult family dooms you, which is the thing people say when they are looking for permission to leave. Marriages were most stable when partners felt good about each other regardless of their families. A strong partnership carried people through unsupportive relatives.
What family seems to do is set your margin. It is not the engine of the marriage. It is how much room you have when the engine is struggling. A couple with a good marriage and a hard family gets through. A couple with a strained marriage and a hard family has nothing underneath them.
That is why these questions are worth asking before the wedding rather than after. You are not screening for a perfect family. You are finding out how much margin you are signing up for.
One more detail from the same research group is worth knowing. A separate study of 375 couples over their first 9 years sorted people into four patterns in how they felt about their partner’s parents: mostly helpful, mostly ambivalent, mostly indifferent, mostly difficult. Couples who later divorced were more likely to have been in the ambivalent, indifferent or difficult groups than the helpful one.
Indifference was not a safe place. Feeling nothing much about the family you married into carried risk too, not just feeling hostile.
The finding about parents who divorced
Since it will be on your mind if it applies to you: yes, parental divorce raises the odds. In the research on this, a woman whose parents divorced has roughly 69% higher odds of divorcing herself, and when both partners come from divorced families the increase is much larger.
The nuance is the useful part, and almost nobody repeats it.
Children of parents who stayed married but were clearly miserable did not show elevated divorce risk. And transmission was strongest when the parents who divorced had reported low conflict beforehand, not high.
The reading most researchers take from that is that what transmits is not the experience of conflict. It is something closer to a belief about how permanent a marriage is. Watching a marriage end without visible cause teaches that marriages can simply end. Watching two people stay and struggle teaches something else.
So the question to ask is not “did your parents divorce”. It is what they concluded about marriage afterwards.
The 20 questions
Ask these over months, not in one sitting. A list delivered as an interview will get you performance, not information.
How the family actually works
- Who makes the decisions in your family, and how did you work that out?
- What happens when someone in your family says no to something?
- Who are you closest to, and who do you quietly avoid?
- What does your family expect to be told, and what do they expect to be asked?
- What is the thing your family does not talk about?
Money and obligation
- Does anyone in your family depend on you financially now, or expect to later?
- What do your parents expect from you as they get older, practically and financially?
- Has money ever been lent or given between people in your family, and how did that end?
- What would your family expect us to contribute to, and would we be asked or told?
Conflict and repair
- Tell me about the last real argument in your family. What happened afterwards?
- Is anyone in your family not speaking to anyone else, and why?
- When your family disapproves of something you have done, what do they actually do?
- Has your family ever been wrong about a person, and did anyone admit it?
After the wedding
- How often do you expect us to see your parents?
- Where are we spending the major holidays, and who decides that?
- If your mother and I disagree in front of you, what do you do?
- What would have to happen before you would take my side against your family?
What they took from it
- Which of your parents’ habits do you think you have?
- What did watching their marriage teach you about how a marriage runs?
- What do you want to do differently from them, and have you started?
Questions 16 and 17 are the two that matter most, and they are the two people skip. Everything before them is information. Those two are about whether a new household is going to exist as its own thing.
How to ask, and who to ask
There is a small study worth knowing about here. Researchers followed 60 engaged couples and their mothers, 240 people in total, surveying them about 6 months before the wedding and again 6 to 8 months after.
The thing that predicted a stronger relationship with a partner’s parents after the wedding was spending time with them one to one, without your partner in the room.
Time spent all together did not do it. Some of it was associated with worse outcomes, most likely because group settings are where performing happens and nothing real gets said.
Two other findings from the same study. People who went in worried the relationship would never get close had more conflict later. So did people carrying specific unspoken concerns about divided loyalty or how grandchildren would be handled. The worry itself seemed to do work, probably by shaping how people behaved.
That study is small and narrow. The participants were almost entirely White, Protestant, well educated and living in one American city, so it does not describe every family and it certainly does not describe families where meeting a partner’s mother alone before a wedding would be inappropriate. Take the mechanism rather than the instruction. The point is that the relationship you build with a family is built in specific, direct conversations, not at gatherings.
What to do with the answers
Nothing on this list is a disqualification. A family with debts, silences and a long running argument is a normal family.
What you are listening for is narrower than good or bad:
Does he know the answers? Someone who has never noticed how decisions get made in his own family will not notice how they get made in yours.
Can she say it plainly? A person who cannot describe a family problem without defending it is not going to be able to negotiate with it later.
Is there a household forming? Questions 16 and 17 tell you whether he has thought about being a husband as a distinct role from being a son. Plenty of people have not, and that is fine at 24 and a serious problem at the wedding.
We have written before about why your family wanting a say is not automatically a problem, about the questions worth asking each other before marriage, and about how the load bearing topics like money tend to get left until last. This is the same argument pointed at a different room in the house.
Where this leaves VOOWA
None of this is a thing a platform can answer for you. Families are found out slowly, in person, over a long time.
What a platform can do is stop you spending a year on someone before these questions are even askable. On VOOWA, marriage intention is stated before the first message, and the subjects that decide how a household actually runs, faith and how it is practiced, family involvement, what someone is actually looking for, sit at the front rather than surfacing in month 8. Verification is free, and each check is done by a real person.
The questions above are still yours to ask. You will just get to ask them sooner, of someone who is there for the same reason.
VOOWA is now on Google Play, and joining is free. The download is just below. Once you are in, invite friends with your invite link or your personal code: when 11 of them join and get verified, you get a month of Basic free, and at 22, a month of Premium.